Improve by subtraction
Choosing well takes a thousand reasons. Ruling something out takes one.
Ask people who have done unusually well how they made their best decisions, and many will say it just happened. It sounds like luck, and partly it is. But when the same person gets lucky again and again, the luck deserves a closer look.
Ask an eighteen-year-old what they want to study and you will get hesitation. Ask what they would never study and the answers come at once, with reasons. Choosing and ruling out are different questions, and the second is much easier to answer well. To choose, you have to weigh every criterion. To rule something out, one reason is enough: we can’t carry the risk, we don’t have the time.
So I start by removing the options that could hurt badly. What remains ranges from ordinary to excellent, and at that point the exact pick matters less than it seems. Even bad luck can’t do much damage, because the damaging options are already off the table. Repeat that often enough and luck gets many chances to turn up something great. The people who call themselves lucky had first learned to keep only good cards in front of them.
Nassim Taleb calls this via negativa. Complex systems rarely pick the best solution; they shed the weakest. A plant loses its weakest cells over winter and comes back stronger. An economy improves when failing firms make room. A product improves when you remove features until nothing is left to remove.
Subtraction alone won’t hand an ordinary person everything they want. Complex systems get away with it because they live long relative to each decision; we may get ten real decisions in a working life. What steadily removing the bad options does is keep us going through the ups and downs and the tiring forks in the road, so that when the conditions are right we still have the time and energy for an extraordinary decision.